A detailed taxpayer receipt
Sunday, October 03, 2010
We're always advised to get receipts for our tax-related expenditures. Not having documentation could be quite costly if the IRS ever questions an itemized deduction or business expense.
Well, the folks at Third Way, which describes itself as "the leading moderate think-tank of the progressive movement," took that taxpayer documentation concept to the next level.
"We suggest that everyone who files a tax return receive a taxpayer receipt.' This receipt would tell them to the penny what their taxes paid for based on the amount they paid in federal income taxes and FICA," said David Kendall and Jim Kessler, policy specialists for the group.
The duo took a collection of data (polls, IRS statistics and government budget documents) and came up with the payment ticket shown below (or on page 3 of their full taxpayer receipt brief).
The $34,140 figure used to create the Third Way taxpayer receipt came from the IRS.
In their report, Kendall and Kessler say that IRS data show that for 2008, that was the adjusted gross income for the median U.S. tax return filer. Starting with that figure, say Kendall and Kessler in their report, "it's really very easy" to come up with the receipt:
"The total amount of federal spending is the denominator and the amount of money spent on a particular program is the numerator. The resulting quotient is the percentage of all federal spending that goes to that program. For example, the amount of money spent on Pell Grants in fiscal year 2009 was $19.38 billion, which is divided by total federal spending of $3.518 trillion. This means that 0.55% of all federal spending went to Pell Grants. Multiply this number by the amount a taxpayer paid in taxes (in this case $5,400) and that means this person contributed $29.75 to Pell Grants."
Some folks have already raised question about the actual numbers and the calculation method. But the concept itself is intriguing.
And Third Way contends that it wouldn't be too difficult or too expensive for Uncle Sam to do the same for each of us.
"The mathematical formula to do this is very simple. The Social Security Administration does this every year through the mail to tell people what they can expect from Social Security in the future. This would be far easier. It could also be done online. An IRS website should be available so people could key in the amount they pay in taxes and a receipt pops up showing several dozen recognizable programs and the amount that went to each of them."
The bigger hurdle likely would be getting Congress to authorize the IRS to create website receipt calculator.
I'm not sure a bipartisan majority of Senators and Representatives want to know the per-taxpayer spending breakdown themselves, much less share the info with us!
- Graphic looks at where your taxes go
- How your tax dollars are spent
- Where do our tax dollars go?
- Tracking your tax dollars
- A look at who's paying how much taxes
- Death and Taxes 2010
- An artful look at Death and Taxes
Want to tell your friends about this blog post? Click the Tweet This or Digg This buttons below or use the Share This icon to spread the word via e-mail, Facebook and other popular applications. Thanks!
"It's so upsetting that funding for the arts is at the very bottom. So sad."
It doesn't upset me. Art is a completely personal and should be supported as such. There's no need for my .25 to indulge someone else's taste in music, sculpture, or paintings. Classical art and music will still be around if the NEA disappears.
What is a tad disturbing is how much money is getting dumped into social services. What I mean that is Social Security and Medicare and Medicaid will need more funding in the near future. I don't see how we even keep level funding and support foreign wars and the national debt. I'm not against social safety nets but I'm not sure I see how we afford everything going forward.
Posted by: Amy | Tuesday, October 05, 2010 at 07:25 PM
I think a lot of tax payers would be shocked and dismayed if they saw how their tax dollars were spent. This receipt concept is a way to bring the govt.'s tax spending to a very personal level.
Posted by: Sonja | Monday, October 04, 2010 at 04:52 PM
It's so upsetting that funding for the arts is at the very bottom. So sad. Great blog by the way.
Posted by: Christy Pinheiro | Monday, October 04, 2010 at 12:30 AM