« Swiss considering 'foreigner tax pledge' | Main | Tax record keeping song and dance »

Monday, November 16, 2009

TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.typepad.com/services/trackback/6a00d8345157c669e20120a6a7f205970b

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Making Work Pay tax problems ... again:

Comments

Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.

pam underwood

what a bunch of crap! The IRS states my husband received the $250, we didn't even know it (I didn't receive the credit). Turbo Tax rejected the efile, corrected it and owed $250 more. Very aggravating.

Henry

Yeah basically we are screwed. In our second careers we are now in the other "middle class" - those who earn less than $50k a year total income. When you earn less - less taxes are taken out. It becomes complicated if you both work because your incomes add to a higher number. We we're wacked with a $900 tax bill in '08. So in '09 we adjusted our withholdings up but it now seems this withholding scheme has left us with a $1.5K tax bill.

Katrina Bond

This exact thing he warns of is happening. My husband works for the State of GA and they took out $1000 less in federal taxes last year and now we owe all of it back. Bastards. $#$% Obama.

Rick

@John: Based on real life checks for two married individuals filing jointly, the stimulus amount is $133 per month ($66.66 each) each; I didn't make that number up. The stimulus is received for 10 paychecks as it started in March. The excess over the credit received is going to be $530.

If you didn't notice the extra $133 in your bank account each month, I'm guessing you will notice the $530 reduction in your refund!

John Kelly

The spin from IRS is interesting (today's Wash Post). They downplay the 15.4 million taxpayers claiming TIGTA have double counted. TIGTA admitted they double counted a grand total of 2,681 filers. Then they claim that "the vast majority will only receive a slightly reduced refund." That is because 3/4 (their "vast majority") of filers "receive refunds which averaged more than $2,800."

First, this is not a "slight" reduction. According to the TIGTA report, this applies to groups of taxpayers who are ineligible for the credit in $200 to $1,000 increments. Hardly slight for the middle class taxpayer it was intended to help.

Second, the fact that 3/4 of filers receive a tax refund is a red herring. Whether it's coming out of a paycheck or coming out of a refund check, it's still coming out of the taxpayer's pocket.

Third, yes, the average tax refund check is probably more than $2,800 - including those in the higher income brackets who, if they receive a refund, probably drive up the average. And they never qualified for the credit.

Fourth, they got other credits for buying appliances, and cars and first-time homes (Really? You want to bring that up?) so they probably won't notice a few hundred dollars missing from their refund.

There's more but I'm dizzy.

John Kelly

I strongly suspect this will get a lot of attention in coming weeks. @Rick: Not surprising people didn't notice an extra $12 in their paychecks but they will notice when they owe the IRS $300 in January.

TIGTA's recommendations are silly:

1. Media coverage (announce to the world that 15M middle class taxpayers have to pay back the relief they thought they were getting).

2. IRS withholding calculator (recalculate your withholding, submit new W-4 to payroll, hope paycheck is adjusted in the next 5 weeks).

Rick

During one our 2009 tax updates classes, I was surprised how many people didn't even notice the change in their paycheck when this went into effect last Spring. I did of course ask the question whether everyone was getting paid more than me. But if a group of tax preparers aren't aware of the problem, some of the more complicated situtations you listed above are certainly going over the head of the average worker. The intended stimulus may turn into a May 2010 anti-stimulus. Great post!

Kay @ Don't Mess With Taxes

Thanks, John, for the quick math!

John Kelly

Then it would appear that the Making Work Pay Credit has about a 10% error rate (putting it on par with the homebuyer credit). The report also indicates that the errors $200-400 range and will result in a $4 billion hit on filers next year. All back of the envelope.

The comments to this entry are closed.

Weekly Tax Tip

  • Dealing with a wrong refund --
    Your refund finally arrived, but it's not what you expected. Now what? Regardless of whether the refund amount is less than you figured on your 1040 or is more, there are some steps you can take to resolve the matter. First, find out why. The discrepancy could be due to math errors in figuring your tax bill, incorrect credit or deduction claims, improperly credited estimated tax payments or offsets to cover other debts, such as an unpaid federal student loan or missed child support payments. If it's a tax return related issue, the Internal Revenue Service will send you written notice of why your refund amount is not what you expected. If it's an offset, the Treasury Offset Program will do the same. If your tax records support the refund amount you claimed, let the IRS know. And if you find an error before the IRS does, file an amended return to correct it.
    (April 23, 2013)

  • Tax Tip; click pencil for all tax tip links


  • Check out all the latest post-April 15 advice at Weekly Tax Tips 2014.

    You also can get a refresher of the Daily Tax Tips posted earlier this year on their respective monthly collection pages: January, February, March and April.

A few words from
our paid sponsors

Counting Down to Tax Day

Time for Tax Tasks


  • monthly tax moves

  • April 1: Today is April Fool's Day, but don't you be a tax fool.

    April Fools Day jack in the box drawing; click image for more on this holiday

    If you got or expecting a big refund, or ended up owing a lot, then now's the time to adjust your payroll withholding.

    April 4: It's a bit late in the filing season to hire a tax professional, but you still might be able to get some free tax help through such programs as Volunteer Income Tax Assistance (VITA) and Tax Counseling for the Elderly (TCE).

    April 10: Yes, Tax Day is just around the corner, but you still have to take care of other tax tasks. If your job includes tips and you received $20 in tips in March, use Form 4070 to report them today to your employer.

    April 12-13: This last weekend before your 1040 is due doesn't have to be a lost weekend.

    Don't get in such a rush that you make common mistakes on your tax return.

    April 15: This is it! Tax Day 2014.

    April 15 calendar page; click image to go to IRS website

    There are lots of tax tasks to take care of today, so let's get to them.

    Your 2013 personal income tax return is due today, either by sending it electronically or getting it to the post office so it can be postmarked by midnight, local time. And don't forget about Free File.

    IRS Free File; click image for details

    The IRS partnership with more than a dozen tax software manufacturers is open for taxpayers whose adjusted gross income is $58,000 or less not only through today's deadline, but also through the Oct. 15 filing extension.

    If you just can't complete your forms, file Form 4868 to get an automatic six-month extension. But be sure to pay any tax you owe. It's an extension to file, not an extension to pay.

    If you didn't file a return in 2010, you could be missing out on your part of almost $760 million in tax refunds that were never claimed. Today also is the last day you can file that old return and get your refund from that tax year. Miss filing and Uncle Sam gets to keep your money.

    Today is the last chance to make a 2013 contribution to your IRA, either Roth or traditional accounts.

    If you have a health savings account (HSA), today's the final day to contribute and maximize your 2013 deductions to this medical insurance plan.

    If you make estimated tax payments then your 2014 first-quarter 1040-ES voucher for is due today.

    To ensure that you don't miss any tax saving possibilities, check out the 2014 Daily Tax Tips. Links for each month are under the tax tip pencil icon near the top of this column.

    And don't forget your state taxes. Most states with income taxes follow the federal filing deadline.

    April 21: Now that filing is done (except for us procrastinating filing extenders), take some time to store your tax records. You need to hang onto some filing paperwork just in case the IRS has follow-up questions.

    April 28: Were you one of those organized folks who filed earlier but are still waiting for your refund? Track it down with the IRS' online refund locator.

    Small Business Tax Calendar: Important filing, deposit and record keeping dates throughout the year that your company needs to know. You also can view the full year's important business tax dates in IRS Pub. 509.

State Tax Help

  • Don't forget your state taxes!
    Forty-three states and D.C. collect personal income taxes. But even if you live in of the seven states without an income levy, you still face other state (and local) taxes.

    State Tax Departments provides links to your state's Web page. The companion page, Tax Tidbits, is the compilation of blurbs about each state's tax laws. And for more state tax news, check out all our state tax bloggings.

What are you looking for?

  • Looking for something in particular? Start with the Table of Contents.
    Or check out the Archives, where you can review posts by month and category. Or enter specific keywords in the box below to search Don't Mess With Taxes.

Subscribe: E-mail,
RSS or both!

The Truth About
Paying Fewer Taxes

  • Are you a tax geek? Got tax geek friends? Do you or they just want to make sure you don't overpay the IRS? Then my book, "The Truth About Paying Fewer Taxes," is for all y'all.

    Look for it on bookstore shelves or order from Amazon and Barnes & Noble.


  • TruthAboutTaxes

  • Find out more about my book, read excerpts, even listen to a podcast at the FT Press Truth About Paying Fewer Taxes Web page.

Read more by me at ...

Tax Reading Room

  • Don't Mess With Taxes
    is an Amazon Affiliate.
    If you click
    on the product links above
    and/or buy the items,
    I will be compensated.

More me on the Web

Et Cetera


  • Plutus Financial Bloggers Awards
    Best Tax Blog, 2013

  • Association for Women 2012 Clarion Award Winner
    National Association
    for Women in Communications
    Best Personal Blog, 2012

  • Plutus Award Winner
    Plutus Financial Bloggers Awards
    Best Tax Blog, 2011


  • Alltop

  • pfblogs.org logo

My Photo

Keep Uncle Sam cranky!

  • It's no wonder Uncle Sam is not very happy here. His vault is empty. Don't Mess With Taxes aims to keep him cranky by providing tax and personal finance tips and advice that will put more money in your bank account, not the government treasury.

I gotta tell ya ...

  • AKA Disclaimer:
    I am a professional journalist who has been covering tax issues since 1999.
    I am not a professional tax preparer.
    The content on Don't Mess With Taxes is my personal opinion based on my study and understanding of tax laws, policies and regulations. It’s provided
    for your private, noncommercial, educational and informational purposes only. It’s not a recommendation or endorsement of any company or product. In other words, specifically the words in Treasury Circular 230 Notice, any U.S. tax advice on this blog is not intended or written to be used, and cannot be used, for the purpose of (1) avoiding penalties under the Internal Revenue Code or (2) promoting, marketing, or recommending to another party any transaction or matter addressed on this blog. That's why when it comes to filing your taxes,
    I urge you to get additional, professional, paid-for guidance from an accountant, Enrolled Agent or other qualified tax professional who is familiar with your individual tax circumstances.

©©©©© & ®®®®®

DMWT Mobile

  • Don't Mess With Taxes
    is now optimized for readers on the go. You don't even need an app. Just type dontmesswithtaxes.typepad.com into your smartphone or other mobile device and it will load in a format
    for smaller browsers.

Keeping count

  • eXTReMe Tracker


  • Site Meter (since 061706)


    StatCounter (since 040513)

Where in the World?

Blog powered by Typepad
Member since 11/2005

April 2014

Sun Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat
    1 2 3 4 5
6 7 8 9 10 11 12
13 14 15 16 17 18 19
20 21 22 23 24 25 26
27 28 29 30